[Skip to Content]Privacy Policy
 
Smithtown, NY 631-724-3242

Wedding Venue Reviews in Long Island

We take great pride in hosting world-class events and strive to earn 100% satisfaction from all of our clients. From white glove service to our newly renovated facilities with an elegant atmosphere, read these genuine reviews to see what people are saying about their experiences with Watermill Caterers.
Discover why we are one of the best venues in Long Island for unforgettable weddings, corporate events, Bar/Bat Mitzvahs, Sweet 16 birthdays, anniversaries and much more.
Read or Write Reviews on
Testimonials
Read all of our wedding reviews on our Watermill Caterers Storefront at Wwlogo 83x19

Wonderful Experience

November 11, 2016, unknown
We had our ceremony (indoor) and reception at the Watermill and it was beyond five stars! The food was exquisite - we are still receiving compliments! The staff was amazing - throughout the entire planning process (love Samantha and Brian!) and the day of staff that we worked with were truly wonderful. Richard (maitre' d) and Jenn (our bridal attendant) kept the whole day running smoothly. I felt so taken care of and they were a pleasure to have alongside us. As well as all the other staff members who I sadly don't remember all their names - from the bartenders, captain of the wait staff, the wait staff, the parking attendants - everyone was simply fabulous. I am so happy we decided to have our wedding at the Watermill!
Service
Rooms
Quality
Value
Location
Cleanliness

Amazing!

September 28, 2016, Hayley stabile
Unfortunately I'm unable to leave more than five stars, which I totally would. We booked our wedding with Tom, who was so awesome from the start and all the way to the very end!! Mind you I was calling almost every other week asking questions, and everyone was so great and extremely helpful!! We had our wedding there this past Sunday and I can't say enough good things! Caitlin was my bridal attendant, she worked her butt off and was absolutely amazing! Very attentive to me and my family and bridal party. Nick was our maitre'd , this guy was the key with everything going off without a hitch. Everything went so smoothly, and I wasn't bothered with anything! He was on top of it! Rich was our captain and he was another behind the scenes guy that just made everything go so smooth! The food was incredible, and the cocktail hour was out of this world. I'm still hearing from guests how delicious everything was! I totally recommend this place in the highest regard!!
Service
Rooms
Quality
Value
Location
Cleanliness
previous