[Skip to Content]Privacy Policy
 
Smithtown, NY 631-724-3242

Wedding Venue Reviews in Long Island

We take great pride in hosting world-class events and strive to earn 100% satisfaction from all of our clients. From white glove service to our newly renovated facilities with an elegant atmosphere, read these genuine reviews to see what people are saying about their experiences with Watermill Caterers.
Discover why we are one of the best venues in Long Island for unforgettable weddings, corporate events, Bar/Bat Mitzvahs, Sweet 16 birthdays, anniversaries and much more.
Read or Write Reviews on
Testimonials
Read all of our wedding reviews on our Watermill Caterers Storefront at Wwlogo 83x19

Exceptional Service

April 11, 2017, Jen
My husband and I had our wedding here Saturday 4/8/17. Our experience with the venue was nothing short of perfect from inception to completion. Our Banquet manager Brian was exceptional in the services he provided and was always available to answer questions we had along the way. He helped us select a package that fit our overall needs. The packages were completely customizable (e.g.: we created a Caribbean station for cocktail hour) and there were options for many exquisite additions (e.g.: ice sculptures, chocolate fountain and to-go station of cookies and brownies). Along the way we worked with other members of Watermill staff (Samantha and Tom) who were equally helpful and accommodating. The day of our wedding Richard and Jen ( our Maitre,D and Bridal Attendant) did not leave our sides. They made sure not only the groom and I, but our entire bridal party (approx 30 people!) were fed and well taken care of. Their service was speedy and efficient throughout the night. We received many compliments about the food and how good it was. It was truly a night to remember. I highly recommend the Watermill for anyone who wants an exceptional venue with exceptional service and food.
Service
Rooms
Quality
Value
Location
Cleanliness

Thank you

March 27, 2017, Kim & Mike
Hi Tom, Mike & I are boarding our flight now, but wanted to send you a quick note to tell you how incredible your staff was! We felt so taken care of, they were beyond accommodating & everything (food, set up, venue itself) left us speechless! Our guests will not stop telling us how impressed they are!!!! Tom was simply incredible! Clearly he has so much experience & it shows! Katelyn - there are no words! I don't know what I would have done without her honestly! All night I had an issue with my dress & she kept helping me & was the reason why I was able to dance all night! She was so attentive & sweet & we just adored her! Danielle also was amazing! We definitely had a dream team! Your venue is unbelievable & I will be writing excellent reviews when I return! Please let me know the best way to get the word out there. THANK YOU for everything! Big hugs! I'm so grateful we chose the Watermill! AMAZING!!! We are so happy!!!!!! 😁 Best, Kim & Mike
Service
Rooms
Quality
Value
Location
Cleanliness
previous