[Skip to Content]Privacy Policy
 
Smithtown, NY 631-724-3242

Wedding Venue Reviews in Long Island

We take great pride in hosting world-class events and strive to earn 100% satisfaction from all of our clients. From white glove service to our newly renovated facilities with an elegant atmosphere, read these genuine reviews to see what people are saying about their experiences with Watermill Caterers.
Discover why we are one of the best venues in Long Island for unforgettable weddings, corporate events, Bar/Bat Mitzvahs, Sweet 16 birthdays, anniversaries and much more.
Read or Write Reviews on
Testimonials
Read all of our wedding reviews on our Watermill Caterers Storefront at Wwlogo 83x19

Thank you

July 14, 2017, Raphael & Marissa Dimayuga
We would like to thank you for putting together an amazing event for us. Our experience at the Watermill far exceeded our expectations, which were already high to begin with. The Watermill is beautiful and perfect for a rustic and elegant wedding. All of our rustic decorations fit in perfectly with the natural beauty of the gardens outside and contrasted perfectly with the elegance inside. You and your team were very professional, kind, organized and accommodating. Nick, the Maitre'd guided us through the day so that everything ran smoothly facilitating our photographs, ceremony, entrance and anything else we needed so smoothly. One of or recently married friends mentioned how organized everything ran that day, and that was due to your staff. Angela was always around whenever Marissa wanted anything. Whether it was to hold her bouquet, get a drink, or even bustle her dress, she was by her side to help! Danielle, the captain was amazing and made us feel very special. She complimented our cake, our chair holders that fit the chairs, and the decorations. She also found a perfect place for one of the signs that we brought, high above the fireplace so it could be seen by all. There was an incident where a candle spilled wax on the floor and we felt awful! She and Nick not only had it cleaned up, she reassured us that it was no problem. It's so nice to not feel guilty on your wedding day because the people who are working hard around you are also sweet and nice. The entire day, we felt very comfortable and confident knowing that your team had things under control. The food was superb, especially the amazing cocktail hour. We had so many compliments on how good the food was and the on the selection. The presentation and the quality of it all were impeccable. The cake, which was provided from Dortoni's, was stunning and delicious. One uncle said it was the best wedding cake he ever ate! The venue was beautiful inside and out. I felt like I had the best of both words. I had beautiful garden photographs, elegant ones in the chapel and empty ballroom, and super fun dancing ones during the party. Nick picked purple uplighting that matched our theme perfectly and my day wedding felt like a night wedding as soon as we went downstairs. We had been worried that since we chose a day wedding it wouldn't be as fun, and it wasn't just fun. It was a blast! Our wedding was the best wedding we'd ever been to and that's what every couple should feel like on their wedding day. Thank you so much for everything you did to keep it running smoothly even when we had last minute additions (table numbers and programs!) Thank you to Nick, Angela and Danielle for all of their wonderful work and help! We really did have the best wedding experience we could have. Thank you from the bottom of our hearts for giving us a day we will always remember! Love, Raphael & Marissa Dimayuga
Service
Rooms
Quality
Value
Location
Cleanliness

Wonderful!

June 12, 2017, June and Mark Rabin
My daughter-in-law and son were married on Saturday June 10th. We are thrilled they chose your venue. Everything was fantastic. Your staff is excellent and saw to every guests needs. The service is impeccable. Jackie is extremely organized and thorough. She made sure all of our concerns were taken care of. We had one guest with dietary needs and your chef phoned her to go over the menu- not just for the dinner but the cocktail hour as well. That shows how your establishment takes the extra step. Thank you for a wonderful wedding and great experience.
Service
Rooms
Quality
Value
Location
Cleanliness
previous