[Skip to Content]Privacy Policy
 
Smithtown, NY 631-724-3242

Wedding Venue Reviews in Long Island

We take great pride in hosting world-class events and strive to earn 100% satisfaction from all of our clients. From white glove service to our newly renovated facilities with an elegant atmosphere, read these genuine reviews to see what people are saying about their experiences with Watermill Caterers.
Discover why we are one of the best venues in Long Island for unforgettable weddings, corporate events, Bar/Bat Mitzvahs, Sweet 16 birthdays, anniversaries and much more.
Read or Write Reviews on
Testimonials
Read all of our wedding reviews on our Watermill Caterers Storefront at Wwlogo 83x19

Thank you

December 06, 2018, Guest
A very warm thank you to you and your staff who helped host our Annual Radiology Holiday Party on December 4, 2018. Nick and staff did an excellent job on your behalf. As usual, you and your staff did a superb job in service and food. I received many raves on your food and beautiful decoration. We had a great time, and it was wonderful to gather with friends, associates and colleagues to celebrate the season. We look forward to seeing you again next year! Happy Holiday to you and your staff.
Service
Rooms
Quality
Value
Location
Cleanliness

Thank you

November 07, 2018, Guest
Hi Tom, Kaitlyn, Shaun, Anthony and all of the Watermill staff, Jesse and I are just starting to unwind from the wedding whirlwind and we would like to take this time to thank your staff for the amazing service on our wedding day. We are still receiving compliments from guests who were floored by the impeccable food, service, ambiance, and entertainment from that special night. Tom- From the very beginning, you were absolutely amazing in every event leading up to our wedding day. From the minute I stepped into the Vanderbilt room, I was in love, and you helped to carry out my dream wedding just as I always pictured it. Not only did you treat us like VIP, but you were not pushy like many other banquet managers we met with prior. I would like to thank you for always being available to answer my text messages with crazy wedding questions and always putting my mind at ease. You were so understanding and accommodating, especially with my father, as the time got closer, and that means a lot to my family. Thank you for hand picking the best of the best to make our night perfect. You were honest and straight forward from beginning to end, and your top priority was to make Jesse and me feel happy on our wedding day. You're the best! Kaitlyn- There are simply not enough words to express our gratitude for you. You are some sort of magical angel from the wedding heavens! Every single detail was accounted for because of you. I honestly did not even realize that you were helping out my bridal party as well as us until our best man told us that you went to find him at the bar for the sparkler send off so that he didn't miss it. When my bustle broke, all three times, you were there to fix it with a safety pin. Throughout the night, you always made sure that I was comfortable, fed, and happy. You were so kind, and courteous and did everything with a smile on your face. Something that really meant a lot to me was when I asked you to make sure the photographer got a picture of my "something blue"- the blue hearts from my grandparents' clothing on the inside of my dress. I had almost forgotten about that and the photographer remembered, because of you! So thank you for that. Our bridal party and our families were able to have fun and relax, because you had it all covered! It's amazing how you are able to be in so many places at once! And you served food too! (Magician) I'll never forget how you began asking me questions about how Jesse and I met, and our first date, just as I was about to walk down the aisle. I was so nervous, and you helped me to calm down and focus my attention on my love for Jesse instead of my nerves. It was a small gesture, but it meant a lot. I will forever cherish you for how much you cared for us the day of our wedding. Good luck in your future endeavors, whether you choose to pursue science, or flight- I hope those around you treat you as kindly and as warmly as you treat others. Shaun- Thank you for being on top of everything! You and Kaitlyn worked so nicely together to make sure that everything went smoothly. We would like to thank you for being so calm mannered throughout the evening, it really helped us to relax and enjoy our wedding. You were available at any moment we needed you, gracefully guiding us through each step. You made sure that all of our little moments were carried out so perfectly- and we cannot thank you enough for that. Something as small as turning down the blue accent uplighting was done immediately after we asked, and without an issue. Surely your work "behind the scenes" went deeper than we would know, but you never ceased to look cool, calm and collected, with a smile on your face. Anthony- Thank you for making the reception and the food run so smoothly. You were so kind, always making sure that Jesse and I were fed and satisfied from the beginning to the end of the night. The wait staff at the Watermill is absolutely top notch. Jesse and I enjoyed watching them all line up and then so diligently and professionally deliver meals to each table. It seemed so effortless, but we know you were in large part to thank for the efficiency of everyone working that night. We are still getting compliments from people raving about the food and the service that night. It is a huge undertaking, but you made it perfect. The best part was being able to order one of each item on the menu. We wish we could do that at every wedding we attend! Please pass along our heartfelt thanks to all of your staff who helped to make our wedding day so special. You are all so professional and welcoming. Though we are slightly biased, we think we had the best wedding out of any we've ever been to, and that's all thanks to the Watermill staff!! If any of you ever need a client recommendation, we would be happy to help! Thank you, thank you, thank you!! All our best, Stephanie and Jesse Callan
Service
Rooms
Quality
Value
Location
Cleanliness
previous