[Skip to Content]Privacy Policy
 
Smithtown, NY 631-724-3242

Wedding Venue Reviews in Long Island

We take great pride in hosting world-class events and strive to earn 100% satisfaction from all of our clients. From white glove service to our newly renovated facilities with an elegant atmosphere, read these genuine reviews to see what people are saying about their experiences with Watermill Caterers.
Discover why we are one of the best venues in Long Island for unforgettable weddings, corporate events, Bar/Bat Mitzvahs, Sweet 16 birthdays, anniversaries and much more.
Read or Write Reviews on
Testimonials
Read all of our wedding reviews on our Watermill Caterers Storefront at Wwlogo 83x19

Thank you

September 26, 2017, AdeOla C. Fadumiye
Thank you for the quality of service you provided for Amanda and Curette's wedding. Our team truly enjoyed working with your staff. From the Maître d, to the bridal attendant to the captain and to all the staff; service was impeccable and gracious - both rehearsal night and wedding day. I sincerely appreciate working with you and look forward to recommending your venue to our brides and other clients. Sincerely , AdeOla
Service
Rooms
Quality
Value
Location
Cleanliness

Best venue ever!

August 14, 2017, Jessica Wolfsdorf
My husband and I were married here this past July 3rd. It was absolutely amazing!! From the first time we set foot in the building when we were still researching catering halls, we fell in love. The lobby is gorgeous, and we were greeted right away by a friendly receptionist. We mainly worked with Tom Wright, who was nothing but professional, accommodating, and friendly throughout the entire process from beginning to end. The day of the wedding, everything was set up perfectly and the entire staff was excellent. Always on point, accommodating to every guest, and as nice as can be. Sean was our maitre d. He was excellent! He helped me carry my dress while walking around to take pictures, offered us drinks, and made sure we had everything we needed or wanted almost immediately upon asking. Kaitlyn was our bridal attendant who was also amazing. She not only helped my husband and I, but also the entire wedding party throughout the whole night. She was the best!!! On top of amazing service, the food was top notch. Everything from cocktail hour, to dinner (10 choices!!!) to dessert was delicious. We continue to hear compliments about the decor, service, and food from all of our guests. Honestly there isn't a thing we would have changed. The place and the staff are absolute perfection! We will be recommending the Watermill for years to come!!
Service
Rooms
Quality
Value
Location
Cleanliness
previous